The Soviet cinematic genre later dubbed the “Ostern” or “Red Western” by Western observers—action‑adventure narratives set in the remote, often desert, frontiers of the young USSR during the Civil War—found its golden age in the decades following the Second World War. Yet its roots dig deeper into the silent era, and one of the earliest, arguably the very first, exemplars of this distinctly Soviet genre is Yakov Protazanov’s 1927 silent film The Forty-First. While later works like Mikhail Romm’s The Thirteen (1937)—explicitly described in critiques as an early Ostern—would codify the tropes of a desperate band holding out against overwhelming odds in a harsh landscape, Protazanov’s film presents a more intimate, psychologically nuanced prototype. It blends the adventure of survival with a tragic romance, set against the exotic backdrop of Central Asia’s deserts and the Aral Sea, thereby establishing a template that future “Red Westerns” would both follow and simplify.
Protazanov himself is something of an unsung hero of early Russian and Soviet cinema. He was a pre‑revolutionary commercial director who emigrated after the Bolshevik takeover but returned during the comparatively liberal New Economic Policy (NEP) period. His Aelita, though a flawed and loosely‑adapted science‑fiction piece, remains immensely influential for its Martian fantasy sequences and its subversive, almost cynical, view of revolutionary zeal. Protazanov was not burdened by the official Soviet ideology that would later rigidify under Stalin, nor was he driven by the formalist experiments of contemporaries like Eisenstein. He was, at heart, a storyteller attracted to compelling narratives and exotic settings. The Forty-First offered him precisely that: an adaptation of Boris Lavrenyov’s 1924 novel, written while the author—a futurist poet who had served as an armoured‑train commander in Turkmenistan—was editing the Red Army newspaper Krasnaya Zvezda. Lavrenyov drew on his own Civil War experiences in Central Asia, as well as the character of a young female soldier named Anya Vlasova who had pestered him to publish her poetry. This blend of authentic military detail and poetic sensibility translates directly into the film’s unique tone.
The plot is set in what is now Kazakhstan during the Civil War. A Red Army detachment, led by Commissar Yevsukov (Ivan Shtraukh), breaks out of encirclement but must trek through a waterless desert to reach the Red stronghold of Kazalinsk on the Aral Sea. Among them is Maria “Maryutka” (Ada Voytsik), a crack shot who has already killed forty enemy soldiers. After a sandstorm depletes their water, they stumble upon a caravan carrying a single passenger: White Lieutenant Vadim Nikolaevich Govorukha‑Otrok (Ivan Koval‑Samborsky), a courier bearing a vital message from Admiral Kolchak to General Denikin. Capturing him, Yevsukov decides to deliver the prisoner to headquarters. With the aid of sympathetic local herdsmen, they reach a coastal village where only one boat is available for the final leg; Maryutka is ordered to escort Otrok. A sudden storm shipwrecks them on a small, deserted island. There, stripped of the war’s ideological framework, they struggle to survive, gradually shedding their enmity and succumbing to an irresistible physical attraction. Their life together becomes an idyllic, almost utopian interlude—a Robinson Crusoe fantasy mingled with the melodrama of Romeo and Juliet. This idyll shatters when a White aeroplane spots them and a rescue party arrives. As Otrok runs towards his comrades, Maryutka, in a moment of instinctive political duty, shoots him dead. The film closes on her mourning over the body of her lover, the “forty‑first” kill that now carries a profoundly personal cost.
Protazanov’s direction is competent within the technical limits of the era. The Central Asian locations—reportedly authentic, with locals employed as extras—lend the film a palpable sense of place and an ethnographic value rarely seen in Soviet cinema of the time. The depiction of Muslim herdsmen and peasants as sympathetic, ordinary people is noteworthy, offering a precious document of a way of life soon to be altered by collectivisation. However, the film is not without the flaws characteristic of silent cinema. The acting, particularly in the early scenes, tends towards broad, gestural overacting. The editing is occasionally clumsy, and the second half, after the shipwreck, feels somewhat rushed; the transition from enmity to romantic devotion could benefit from more nuanced development. These are, however, minor quibbles in a film that excels in its atmospheric setting and the potent simplicity of its central conflict.
Where The Forty-First truly distinguishes itself is in its daring defiance of what would later become the dogmas of Socialist Realism. Made during the NEP period, when artistic control was relatively lax, the film presents Maryutka not as an idealised Bolshevik heroine but as an uneducated, rough‑edged woman who allows herself to fall in love with a class enemy. Her commitment to the cause is portrayed as almost instinctual, a product of her environment rather than polished ideological conviction. Only in the final moment, when she pulls the trigger, does she conform to the Soviet framework—and even that act is followed by grief, not triumphalism. This psychological complexity was out of step with the soon‑to‑be‑enforced Stalinist aesthetics, which demanded unambiguous heroes and clear moral dichotomies. Unsurprisingly, The Forty-First was largely forgotten or suppressed during Stalin’s reign—a fate not helped by the fact that Ivan Koval‑Samborsky, who played Otrok, was sent to the Gulag in the late‑1930s purges.
The film’s legacy, however, endured. After Stalin’s death and the ensuing “Thaw,” the story was deemed ripe for remake. Despite ideological objections, the politically connected director Ivan Piriyev—husband of Ada Voytsik—pushed the project forward. The 1956 colour and sound version, directed by Grigori Chukhrai as his feature debut, would become a classic in its own right, but it is Protazanov’s silent original that retains a raw, pioneering power. For enthusiasts of silent and early Soviet cinema, The Forty-First is a fascinating curio: a film that straddles genres, blending adventure, romance, and political drama while inadvertently birthing a genre that would later flourish. It may lack the polished craftsmanship of later Osterns, but it possesses an authentic, unvarnished soul that makes it a compelling and historically significant work. Its exploration of love and duty, set against the vast, indifferent desert, remains strikingly resonant nearly a century after its release.
RATING: 5/10 (++)
==
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog @drax.leo
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Leodex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9