A bad choice for anyone considering fostering, but a cracking one for everyone else—Orphan is a jolly, twisted horror that goes places you won’t expect. Starring Vera Farmiga and Peter Sarsgaard as Kate and John, a couple reeling from the trauma of a stillbirth, the film follows their attempt to fill the void by adopting a nine-year-old Russian girl named Esther (Isabelle Fuhrman).
The moment they decide to take in Esther, the orphanage nun’s uneasy smile—delight, tempered by worry—should’ve been a red flag. The strange ribbons around Esther’s neck and wrists, her mysteriously spotty background, her unsettling fixation on her new “daddy”… as the poster bluntly states, “There’s something wrong with Esther.” That “something” turns out to be a long list of deeply disturbing traits—starting with her habit of lurking at the scene of every mishap and escalating to full-blown violence.
SOURCE
In the beginning, Esther seems like a dream. She quickly bonds with the couple’s mostly-deaf daughter, Max (Aryana Engineer), even learning ASL soon after arriving. But her hostility toward Kate, lack of rapport with the couple’s son Daniel (Jimmy Bennett), and oddly adult mannerisms start to raise red flags. Kate becomes increasingly suspicious, but her concerns fall on deaf ears. As a recovering alcoholic with a troubled past—and a husband who once cheated on her—she finds herself gaslit by everyone around her, including her own therapist (Margo Martindale). Esther, meanwhile, expertly manipulates the people around her into believing Kate is losing her mind.
SOURCE
This intense gaslighting is one of the film’s most effective storytelling tools. Screenwriter David Leslie Johnson smartly keeps the focus tight, avoiding unnecessary characters and distractions. We’re locked into Kate’s perspective for long, harrowing stretches, creating an atmosphere of suffocating paranoia. The isolation and helplessness she feels become palpable, and Vera Farmiga’s performance sells every moment—arguably delivering one of her best horror roles.
Then there’s Isabelle Fuhrman, pulling off an astonishing duality. In one scene, she’s angelic and dainty. In the next, she’s threatening a classmate with cutting off his “hairless little prick,” like a scorned Soviet wife. It’s a terrifyingly effective performance, and without her, Orphan wouldn’t be half as memorable.
SOURCE
Unlike many horror flicks about cursed or demonic children, Orphan wisely avoids supernatural tropes. Instead, it leans heavily into psychological horror, and in doing so, creates a much more chilling and grounded experience. One infamous scene (which would make Freud himself take notes) is handled with surprising care—Fuhrman later said the crew made sure she felt safe and fully informed during filming. More stories like that need to be told in Hollywood. Even after all this years, it still holds up.
I will give it a rating of 8/10 cause its just that good