I've never been an Ethereum fanboy. I get it, it's cutting edge technology, huge community support, and well established. After the DAO debacle however, I've been extremely standoffish about it.
Ironically with the increase of ERC20 tokens, I had to get my first Ethereum wallet. People kept trying to send me tokens and I had no wallet. I ended up using myetherwallet.com, it's an online wallet, was fairly easy to use and easy to set up in a pinch. Although it's an online wallet, it acts more as an interface, and users still hold their private keys!
I will admit that as I researched wallets I was impressed by the amount of solutions that are available to Ethereum users. With that said, I wish I would of found this article then. It probably would of saved me a little time and made my life a whole lot easier. Check out this comprehensive article from BTCmanager about Ethereum Wallets.