Which "Beatiful" animation is better

So me and Hive account@quentinty decided to both try and make some pixelart.... And I think we both failed....

Mine, made in the terrible program that Piskel is:

And Hive account@quentinty 's, which he made in GIMP for some unexplained reason, and might've had some... "flashy" problems:

I think we know which one is better already... I just wanted to make a post I guess... Sorry for poluting your place of beatuiful art with this crap.