Totally agree. Every argument ends up the same way nowadays. Although things have been a bit calmer lately since people have had a lot to worry about.
The only possible argument in favor of BTC that I can accept (even though I don't agree) is that the crypto currency market is still too dependent on the ONE currency, and hurting bitcoin would negatively affect the whole "industry".
That said, I think it would be beneficial. Unless BTC quickly gets the lightning network going, I don't see it going anywhere.