I didn´t join because I´m only seeing this post now. But as you mentioned, the prize could have been one of the biggest reasons people did not participate.
I could recommend you to try giveaway cards (bigger community) or if you can afford it some STEEM.
Other than that, the contest looks good, the cleaner and easier to understand the better...
RE: WINNER for the October Better Than Fair to Middlin’ Contest - or - Woe is Me, No More TrickorTreat Tags Do I See!