Thanks for this John, I find it really helpful! I don't think I've ever taken a stab at writing down what makes an artwork meaningful. It's more intuitive: I know it when I see it, and otherwise everything else that I look at simply doesn't cut it. I do like the following quote: "Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos," if this can be applied to all possible levels of meaning.
RE: [redacted]