Good evening to everyone , around 34 hours from now my proposal for SPORTS delegation for Engagement Project will be passed if none of the voters reverse their decision . Before that , I would like to address some fears of few fellow members like Hive account@mk-sports-token .

Concerns

Although I got overwhelming support from other community members like Hive account@cryptoandcoffee , Hive account@uyobong and other large stake holders , I couldn't convince Hive account@mk-sports-token to favour my proposal , I would like to address his fears with an explanation so that if any other community members have same fear , it will be addressed .

In a recent post made by Hive account@rezoanulvibes which is titled "What do you think about the SPORTS Engagement Project" , there are very encouraging comments by other community members except one -

Quoting Hive account@mk-sports-token

Hive account@amr008.sports is a bot, I can imagine that one bot will spam/comment and another bot (amr008.sports) will upvote it and spam with another comment. This is not engagement! This is what I want to downvote.

I completely understand the fear but I will try to answer him -

Two things

1. Yes Hive account@amr008.sports is a bot which replies to top 25 engagers everyday telling their amount of comments, number of authors they have talked to and their rank .

• There are three reasons for this -
  - We are still an young project who need visibility and awareness . We need people to know that engagement matters and quality comments are rewarded .
  - To tell people how they are doing and to motivate them to improve their ranking and the number of comments / number of authors they talk to stats.
  - All the rewards the bot gets ( if any ) will go to engagement project itself and will be paid to delagators which will further encourage participation and delegation .

1. No the bot doesn't upvote bots . It is not at all possible , there is absolutely 0 chance that the bot upvotes another bot - Why ?
   - Because they are not made from the sportstalksocial frontend . I will attach the code snippet here which any other member here can verify -

Code snippet

Test_Query = pd.read_sql_query(''' select * from Comments where parent_author <> '' and created > GETDATE()-2 ORDER BY created DESC ''',conn)


save_list=[]
ignore_list=[]
c=0
for i in range(0,len(Test_Query)):
    try:
        if(Test_Query['created'][i].date()== (dt.utcnow().date()- timedelta(1))):
            json_app= json.loads(Test_Query['json_metadata'][i])
            if 'app' in 'json_app':
                save_list.append([Test_Query['author'][i],Test_Query['parent_author'][i],'@'+Test_Query['author'][i]+'/'+Test_Query['permlink'][i],json_app['app'],Test_Query['created'][i].date(),Test_Query['body'][i]])
    except:
        ignore_list.append([Test_Query['author'][i],'@'+Test_Query['author'][i]+'/'+Test_Query['permlink'][i]])
        c=c+1


df_need=pd.DataFrame(save_list)
df_need_leo=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('leofinance')].reset_index()
df_need_stem=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('stemgeeks')].reset_index()
df_need_ctp=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('clicktrackprofit')].reset_index()
df_need_sports=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('sportstalksocial')].reset_index()

This is a replica of what I use in my script .

I will explain this part step by step -

Test_Query = pd.read_sql_query(''' select * from Comments where parent_author <> '' and created > GETDATE()-2 ORDER BY created DESC ''',conn)

This will read all the comments from past 2 days .

save_list=[]
ignore_list=[]
c=0
for i in range(0,len(Test_Query)):
    try:
        if(Test_Query['created'][i].date()== (dt.utcnow().date()- timedelta(1))):
            json_app= json.loads(Test_Query['json_metadata'][i])
            if 'app' in 'json_app':
                save_list.append([Test_Query['author'][i],Test_Query['parent_author'][i],'@'+Test_Query['author'][i]+'/'+Test_Query['permlink'][i],json_app['app'],Test_Query['created'][i].date(),Test_Query['body'][i]])
    except:
        ignore_list.append([Test_Query['author'][i],'@'+Test_Query['author'][i]+'/'+Test_Query['permlink'][i]])
        c=c+1

This will take each row and stores the following -

1. Author , Parent_author , Permlink , App , Date , Body.

Here the App is very important .

Why ? It tells from which front-end the comment was made -

Ex:

Image Source : https://hiveblocks.com

This is for my recent post made from leofinance frontend - you can see the app part here .

Now let's move to bots -

As you can see here - the app/frontend is "beem".

Edit: I got to know that there is a way to use our own defined frontend name instead of beem . Although its rare that anybody would use this method it is a possibility . In order to prevent this - I will be checking similar comments , repeated comments ( same comments ) etc to make sure this method won't be used to abuse the system.

I am tagging Hive account@abh12345 here to verify or correct me if I am wrong . Also tagging Hive account@patrickulrich .

So where am I checking the 'app' part?

code -

df_need=pd.DataFrame(save_list)

df_need contains -

If you can see here - the column (3) contains the app/frontend details -

now this particular code -

df_need_leo=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('leofinance')].reset_index()
df_need_stem=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('stemgeeks')].reset_index()
df_need_ctp=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('clicktrackprofit')].reset_index()
df_need_sports=df_need[df_need[3].str.startswith('sportstalksocial')].reset_index()

Will store only those which matches particular front-end and ignores others -

df_need_sports output -

If you see this , there doesn't exist any comments which are not made from front-end other than sportstalksocial . So this script calculates only those comments which are made from the sportstalksocial frontend for SPORTS curation .

I am taking measures to prevent spam

1. The project concerns itself only with comments and not posts because there is already Hive account@sportstalksocial account which does that.

2. I am fine tuning the code everyday to introduce more criteria so that the best quality commentors are chosen .

---

This is it from my side . This post is meant to address the fears of the community members and make them aware that this project is not to help few people / bots in any way but to reward genuine users who put effort in engaging with others and contributing to the community .

Finally I would like to thank all those who actually raised questions about this because otherwise I think I would not have posted this explanation . Now I can redirect others here to read about the project.

Feel free to share your opinions here .