Yes, this makes much more sense than the argument for the use of guns.
In the end, it's about violence. And we know up from childhood that violence causes more harm than good.
Your arguments made me thinking if I ever had the true feeling of wanting someone to injure physically or even to kill another human being while being furious. I definitely can say "No". No matter how aroused I got I never felt an urge to kill or destroy a living being.
I find it irritating that you did two separated posts. It can lead to the notion that despite you saying it's not your opinion, it will be taken as agreement as the counter argument is too "far" from reach.
RE: An Argument Against: The Right to Bear Arms