There were two fears that I carried with me into high school. One of them I brought up already and that was spiders. The other was alien abduction so when Fire In the Sky made its way to cable I was going to watch it and I was going to be freaked out by it.
Now most of this movie plays out more like a drama but all it takes is a few scenes to generate a significant amount of nightmare fuel. Anything dealing with the eyes and mouth makes me squeamish and Fire In the Sky gives you both.