Why did you post a rebuttal to his current post in the form of a comment to one of your own posts from 4 months ago? No one will see it. There is sufficient content in that comment to warrant it's own post. Think of the hundreds (perhaps thousands if it had gained traction) who might have seen it, as opposed to the handful that will.

I also notice that you have a habit of compiling a great deal of useful information into comments to other (sometimes your own) original content. I suggest that you rethink this strategy. While the content is indeed captured/ documented someplace for posterity, it is a remarkably inefficient method for ensuring the distribution/ exposure of said content.