This Week’s Property Market Highlights:
- Auction volume was lower across the country.
- Home prices were mostly flat in Sydney but jumped higher in Melbourne.
- A Morgan Stanley economist says overseas Chinese property investment could fall 84 percent this year.
- A Big Four Aussie bank stress tests a 30 percent crash in house prices.
- UBS economists actually believe the RBA can raise rates.
The Latest Preliminary Auction Activity
Sellers brought fewer homes to auction this week, with total auction volume across the capital cities coming in at 1,846, down from 1,987 last week. The preliminary clearance rate was higher, which is to be expected when buyers have less choice.
New South Wales had a bank holiday long weekend, but that didn’t stop Sydney’s preliminary clearance rate lifting back above 70 percent. Melbourne’s market was the hottest in the country again this week. Sales at Auction in Adelaide, Perth, and Canberra were robust, but less than half of Brisbane auctions found a buyer.
Last Week’s Final Auction Results
Only Melbourne and Canberra sellers cleared over 70 percent after the final count was in last week. Demand in both Sydney and Adelaide was moderate, with clearance rates in the mid-60s.
Here are all the final capital city results for last week:
Demand remains strongest in the Eastern Suburbs of Sydney where 88.4 percent of auctions found a buyer. Sellers in the South West continue to struggle finding bids. In the Melbourne suburbs, the Morning Peninsula took out the top spot.
Recent Changes in House Prices
Home prices rebounded this week, thanks to a fall in auction volume. In Sydney, the median house price growth was nominal at 0.17 percent. In Melbourne, home prices surged 0.50 percent week-on-week. Brisbane, Adelaide, and Perth remained relatively flat.
Market Analysis
Changes in home prices in Sydney and Melbourne this week continued to highlight the impact of supply on changes in home prices. Auction volume increased over the previous week, and prices went lower as buyers had more choice. This week, supply decreased, increasing competition between buyers, and prices rose.
Clearance rates are lower in Sydney than in Melbourne, which is an indication that supply is moderating in the New South Wales capital, evidenced also by slower house price growth. Demand is softening because investors are struggling to qualify for stricter lending standards. APRA’s tougher capital controls on banks are having the greatest impact on the Sydney market because home prices are already higher there.
CoreLogic didn’t report on the upcoming auction numbers for next weekend, so we won’t know until tomorrow what volume will look like. If there are fewer sellers again, assuming demand remains consistent with previous weeks, expect more competition amongst buyers and another uptick in home prices.
In the short to medium term, home price growth should remain relatively flat, but expect the Melbourne market to continue to outperform Sydney. If Melbourne’s clearance rate remains in the 70s, home prices will likely continue to grow in the range of 0.50 to 1 percent per month. Prices in Sydney aren’t expected to fall until the auction clearance rate moves below 60 percent for a sustained period.
This Week’s News
Commonwealth Bank Stress Tests a Property Market Crash
There are no micro-economic indicators yet of an impending housing market collapse, but maybe the CBA sees something others don’t. In their latest investor discussion pack, the bank laid out a pretty dark scenario, although perhaps not as bad as things could get.
Their scenario assumes that over a three year period…
- home prices collapse 31 percent,
- unemployment surges to 11 percent, and
- the RBA cuts the cash rate to 0.50 percent.
Here’s what they came up with: They’d need to write off about $4 billion in bad loans, although after getting paid from mortgage insurers, total losses would amount to $2.9 billion. The CBA’s total profit last year was over $9 billion, so a 30 percent price drop wouldn’t be a SHTF scenario for the banks, but shareholders would no doubt be feeling some pain.
Of course, investors wouldn’t fare nearly so well if home prices were to fall 30 percent. They’d be the ones facing foreclosure, and that after months of some very painful cash flow challenges.
Chinese Investment in Aussie Real Estate is Falling Fast
Tougher capital restrictions in China is a big risk for Australian real estate. Chinese investors have made up a significant portion of demand for Aussie homes, especially new builds. If investors can’t get their money out of China, they can’t buy properties overseas.
One Morgan Stanley economist suggests Chinese overseas direct property investment will plummet by 84 percent this year and then fall by another 15 percent by the end of 2018. Only time will tell what that means for the Aussie property market.
Delusional UBS Economists are Forecasting RBA Rate Hikes
Economists at Swiss financial services company UBS have pulled forward their projections of an interest rate hike by the RBA. They expect the Australian economy to grow at 3.5 percent per annum beyond 2019 and suggest the RBA will step in to slow our economy down.
Once again, we have delusional Keynesians buying in to the notion that central banks can actually increase wage growth through lower interest rates.
We currently have a floor under Australian home prices thanks to the RBA’s record low cash rate. Plenty of homebuyers can still afford to pay the interest on very expensive properties. The RBA wants to keep it that way, because without household debt growth, bank profits are screwed.
The last thing any of our regulators want is falling home prices. They want wage prices to rise to wipe out inflation in house prices, so if the economy is growing at 3.5 percent per year, they’ll be celebrating.
Unfortunately for them, interest rates are already at a record low and the economy hasn’t started growing yet. Furthermore, the Aussie dollar has strengthened on a softening US dollar as traders are starting to reject the notion of higher interest rates in the USA.
The RBA wants the Aussie dollar below 70 US cents. Once the Fed starts cutting rates again, we may not see a voluntary rate rise by the RBA until the bond market collapses and drives borrowing costs up independent of the RBA.
Sorry UBS. I just can’t see it.
