"We are already getting like 15 SPS and 2000 merits per brawl."

So it would be a good idea to move to tier 3 as their was your result 19,661 SPS and 2111 merits and the merits (and also the crowns) would increase by roughly 14% when the top-3-bonus is shared between all guilds.

"The proposal which will primarily benefit whales"

Exactly not, the most whales are in top-guilds who reach regularly top-3-positions, so they will even loose rewards but I hope that they see the big picture.

"Many guilds in T2 do not work hard, do not fill many frays, and only use lowest level cards."

Have you spoken to them or how can you be so sure? Don't you think your statement is arrogant towards smaller guilds in Tier 2, who are usually trying to do their best?