No, full disclosure, I don't read everything. Who could possibly do that? Here's my process:

I start with fiction, writing, and craft. Those are my favorites, and the hardest ones to get. Then I look through the introduce yourself posts, looking for something that catches my eye. I do that with the other categories, too. I miss things. I also cheat (shamelessly) for minnows, people on my feed, and women, choosing those posts when I find good ones without directly comparing. I miss a ton of good stuff, for sure, but I feel pretty good that the stuff I choose is quality.