you are right, your original black and yellow fat funky vibe was funkier.

I love the fat funk vibe, but I don't know if it can beat sistem's minimal masterpiece

If he can't fix the airplane in his image, then this one beats it

It oozes funky delicious shiny new vinyl which is still the best platform for fidelity, it also has a funky easy to read font and a rainbow of inclusiveness

and yours second

yours does not capture the vibe of binyl as well, but it is still there quite enough, seriously, and the record player is a bonus.

I almost like your image better becasue our logo is more prominent.

It just hit me what I like about the other one:

Albums have higher fidelity than 45's. Your vinyl is a 45 and his is an LP, so thats why his vinyl vibe beats yours.

But like I said, your logo overlay on the record is superior texturally, so the mere fact that you made a 45 record look as deliscious as an LP is PURE MAGIC MAN!

One big tip I can give you is to change the font!
fix the font