The Bots Are Not Your Friends

I have been querying the blockchain today in an effort to identify abuse of the SteemIt platform. I was expecting to find some serious problems, and the blockchain did not disappoint.

Here's the number of messages posted by a few SteemIt accounts between start of day January 7 and end of day January 8:

Author	Posts	Total Reward Payout
cheetah	3301	481.443
upme	2425	26.175
photocontests	2081	96.344
appreciator	1929	6.999
pushup	1694	0.786
allnatural	1542	0.901
utopian-io	1208	4.954
iamgun	1199	8.06
drotto	1186	0.292
originalworks	1095	1.227
jerrybanfield	804	201.693
steem-network	793	0.022
booster	793	0.543
rewardpoolrape	774	1368.858
postpromoter	630	0.648
boomerang	562	6.77
upmyvote	526	0.396
sneaky-ninja	497	2.701
minnowhelper	488	0.365
jack.the.ripper	477	121.597
harj	461	223.243
levitation	422	0.148
allaz	414	0.112
photocontests2	403	0.562
dimimp	355	91.207
ryox	353	0.435
manuel20	337	0.34
brianyang0912	335	165.755
sumsum007	316	2.458
steemcleaners	305	1126.559
catfacts	305	0.343
puncakbukit	303	246.495
vincentyip	300	319.463
drumz	298	0.00
jangkeum	289	3.347
maneki-neko	282	85.526
mikej	278	9.47
blazing	277	51.722
nnajmull	275	16.269
michaellamden68	270	422.861

Are all of these posters evil? No!

The good guys

Hive account@cheetah and Hive account@steemcleaners are working hard to flag spam and prevent the abuse of the SteemIt platform. Hive account@photocontests does exactly what you would expect a bot by that name to do. And Hive account@catfacts...? Well, it uh... Uhm... It leaves informative facts in the comments. About cats... Rock on buddy! These bots/posters are providing useful or cool services to the community and deserve whatever rewards are coming their way.

The grey area

Automated voting bots. This includes Hive account@pushup, Hive account@upme, Hive account@booster and a few others. Voting bots are okay but I wouldn't call them good. They do good when they're used for good purposes, but more often than not they're used for reward pool abuse rather than the promotion of actual good content. The platform would work better if none of these bots existed, but they can, and are, sometimes used to promote useful content.

The bad guys

These bots are not contributing to the community. These are the guys who are farming the platform for money, farming followers, and generally contributing nothing useful with their posts.

There's a bunch of them, some some are more obvious than others. I find Hive account@rewardpoolrape to be the most honest of the bunch. No mistaking what the bot's doing with that name. Sure enough it has posted hundreds of identical comments all of which read

You're so nice for commenting on this post. For that, I gave you a vote!

For this "useful service" to the community, the rewardpoolrape bot has farmed up an impressive 1368 total rewards (Roughly $5,470 USD at today's prices) over a two day period.

While the abuses of a few of these bots are significant, it is clear that they're not the overwhelming majority of the platform. 48,000 Steem (give or take) is generated per day. Of that 48,000 somewhere around 2,400 (5%) goes to the 50 accounts who post to SteemIt the most frequently.

Given that other individual posters are raking in 4%+ of the reward pool on their own on a daily basis, I'd say the platform has some other problems to address before it starts worrying too much about the handful of bad apples lurking among these 50 accounts.

If you enjoy my posts, don't forget to upvote and

Thanks for reading,

-Matt