You're welcome, Loki. The only other destination I've been to in the vicinity is Puerto Rico. This is, hands down, better than PR. We'll probably do a winter trip to Aruba in 2018. We found a similar Airbnb there.

Saint Thomas is so amazing, in our opinion, because of all of the options for day trips. You can ferry to St. John, St. Croix, and even smaller islands like Water Island. All things considered, it's a pretty good value.