Hi, thank you for taking the time to read my comment and respond. I think that you raise a valid point and I agree with you. Adjustments like this would need to be made to keep the new player experience

Hi, thank you for your interest in my thoughts. Currently, earnings scale directly with rating to the power of 3. If we compare two accounts with different ratings, for example 3k and 4.5k, the account

I think that a lot of people have missed the point of this proposal. This isn't about devaluing old cards, it is about devaluing spellbooks. This view might be easier to swallow for non-botters, but in

While I agree that we should focus on improving rewards for owners of larger collections, I think that it should all come down to rating, which is a simple and intuitive system. Larger collections and

While I agree that we should focus on improving rewards for owners of larger collections, I think that it should all come down to rating. Larger collections and higher-level cards should convert to a higher

I agree that this is the underlying reason why people bot: Fundamentally the problem is that large numbers of low-value accounts out-earn fewer, high-value accounts. I believe that one solution would be

This account really barely earns anything. On top of having no SPS so reward multiplier = 1, it also uses level 1 cards, which are penalized in silver, so also multiply their rewards by ~0.5.